When ChatGPT recommends a local business, it mostly reads review platforms and directories, not business websites. In our August 2026 study across 216 US markets, the most read sites were reviews.birdeye.com, angi.com and expertise.com. Each industry also had an anchor site. Psychology Today showed up in every therapist market and Zillow in nearly every real estate market.
For a local question, ChatGPT searches the web and reads a stack of pages before it answers. We asked "who is the best {service} in {city}" in every market and recorded the web app's answers. For each one we captured which domains were retrieved and which were cited.
Review platforms and directories dominate the reading
Start with the general layer. The most retrieved domain across 215 markets was reviews.birdeye.com. That's where the reputation platform Birdeye hosts review pages for local businesses. It was pulled in 37.7% of markets (81 of 215).
Behind it came angi.com at 24.2%, expertise.com at 21.9% and doctor.webmd.com at 18.1%. Then homeadvisor.com at 17.7% and zocdoc.com at 16.3%.
The cited layer, the sources shown under the answer, told the same story. Birdeye's review pages led at 19.5% of markets (42 of 215). Then came expertise.com at 16.3% and threebestrated.com at 13.0%. These were aggregators and directories, not business websites. The full tables are on the study page, how ChatGPT picks a local business.
Psychology Today and Zillow anchor entire industries
Some categories are very concentrated. Each vertical spanned 18 study markets, and three had a clear anchor.
- Therapists. Psychology Today was cited in 100% of markets (18 of 18).
- Real estate agents. Zillow appeared in 94.4% of markets (17 of 18). The top three sources made up 85.9% of citations (73 of 85).
- Personal injury lawyers. Super Lawyers appeared in 83.3% of markets (15 of 18).
For these three industries, the to-do list starts with one item in bold.
The trades split their citations across a rotation
Home services had no single Psychology Today. Each trade spread its citations across a few recurring sites.
- Window cleaning: angi.com in 52.9% of markets (9 of 17) and threebestrated.com in 47.1% (8 of 17)
- Pool service: threebestrated.com in 50.0% (9 of 18)
- Dentists: reviews.birdeye.com in 50.0% (9 of 18)
- Chiropractors: reviews.birdeye.com in 44.4% (8 of 18)
- HVAC: consumeraffairs.com in 44.4% (8 of 18)
- Plumbers: bestprosintown.com in 44.4% (8 of 18)
- Auto repair (carfax.com) and roofing (expertise.com): 33.3% each (6 of 18)
- Med spas: medspascout.com and discovermedspa.com at 27.8% each (5 of 18)
Some of these are plain unglamorous. Few marketing plans mention Best Pros in Town or Three Best Rated. Yet they kept feeding ChatGPT's answers for the trades.
Coverage across the list beats one perfect listing
Why does the whole rotation matter? Because ChatGPT reads a different subset almost every time. Between two identical asks days apart, the retrieved domains overlapped at just 0.20 on a 0-to-1 scale (n=197 market pairs).
A business listed on one source shows up only when that source gets read. A business listed across the whole rotation shows up on nearly every read. That redundancy turns an occasional mention into a steady one. The churn is broken down in how fast ChatGPT rebuilds its local recommendations.
Reviews ride along with the listings. ChatGPT showed Yelp's rating on about one card in six, as covered in does ChatGPT use Yelp.
Your own website plays the confirming role
The directories introduce you, and your website vouches for the introduction. We crawled 827 of the 936 websites behind the businesses ChatGPT displayed.
Most said what they do and where, in the places machines read first. 63.6% named the service in the page title and 56.5% named the city. 44.5% ran LocalBusiness structured data. Only 13.8% marked up an aggregate rating.
Nothing exotic there. Make sure ChatGPT can reach your site at all, though. OpenAI's crawler documentation says sites that block OAI-SearchBot aren't shown in ChatGPT search answers.
ChatGPT business profiles add one more source
OpenAI opened Business Hub in November 2026. Owners can now claim their business on ChatGPT and manage its profile. OpenAI says ChatGPT may also use other sources when answering about your business. So a claimed profile adds to your directory coverage. It doesn't replace it.
For the full set of steps, from crawl access to reviews, see how to optimize for AI search.
The questions owners ask most about which sources ChatGPT reads, answered from the study data.
Ready to cover the reading list in your category?
The work is concrete. Find your category's anchors and list your business accurately on each source in the rotation. Keep every detail consistent and let your website confirm it. Spearleaf builds this coverage map in our AI search optimization work, market by market. To see which pages mention you and which miss you, reach out through our contact page.
This article was written by Joshua Albanese, founder of Spearleaf, a local SEO and marketing agency based in Fort Myers, Florida. Joshua has built six businesses from zero using organic search and content, and he leads Spearleaf's SEO, AI search, and local strategy for service businesses across the U.S.