Mostly, yes. We checked 216 US markets in August 2026. Most businesses that Google's AI Overviews named were already in the local pack on the same page. The AI Overview usually named one or two, against the pack's three. So the Business Profile work that wins the local pack is also what puts you in the AI answer.
The other posts in this series looked at ChatGPT. This one crosses the street to Google. Alongside the ChatGPT study, we captured city-targeted Google results for the same 216 markets. That's 12 service types across 18 cities, in two phrasings and two waves, 864 desktop captures in all.
Corrected October 2026: an audit found some Google AI Overview figures were affected by a change in our data source's output format. We removed them; the ChatGPT findings are unchanged.
The study captured every market twice in two phrasings
We searched each market two ways. One was conversational, "who is the best {service} in {city}". The other was the keyword form, "best {service} in {city}". Both ran in two waves three days apart.
For each capture we recorded whether an AI Overview appeared and which businesses it named. We also logged what it cited and what the local pack on the same page showed. The full tables are on the study page, how ChatGPT picks a local business.
Across the 216 markets, an AI Overview appeared for 25.9% of market observations (CI 22.8% to 29.3%). That single number hides a lot. The rate swung with phrasing, with industry and from one check to the next.
Question phrasing triggers the AI Overview
"Who is the best plumber in Tampa" triggered an AI Overview 39.1% of the time. "Best plumber in Tampa" triggered one just 12.7% of the time. Same intent, three times the AI coverage, purely from phrasing.
That fits outside research. Pew Research Center's 2025 study of Google users found 60% of searches starting with question words drew an AI summary. As people ask full questions, expect the AI layer to cover more local searches.
Presence was also restless. The same search could show an AI Overview on one check and none on the next. Read every rate here as a rough level for August. It also varied sharply by industry.

AI Overview trigger rate by vertical, 18 markets each. Personal injury lawyers 43.1%. Real estate agents 43.1%. Window cleaning 31.9%. Med spas 30.6%. Pool service 27.8%. Dentists 15.3%. Therapists 13.9%.
Personal injury lawyers and real estate agents already see the AI layer on a large share of "best" searches. Therapists barely see it yet.
AI Overviews mostly repeat the local pack
Now the core finding. When an AI Overview named local businesses, it named few, usually one or two per answer. And most weren't discoveries. They were already in the local pack on the same page.
On this evidence, Google's AI layer draws its local names from the same pool the pack shows. It concentrates visibility more than it redistributes it.
Google's own guidance fits that. Its guide to generative AI features says AI Overviews are rooted in its core ranking systems. It also says an up-to-date Business Profile can help local businesses appear in AI responses.
The local pack holds steady while ChatGPT churns
The second finding is about stability. We measured how much each surface's list repeated between two waves, on a 0-to-1 overlap scale.

Repeat overlap (Jaccard) between two waves on the conversational query. Google local pack 0.82 (n=198 markets, captures 3 days apart). ChatGPT panel 0.36 (n=214, asks 4 to 9 days apart).
The local pack repeated at 0.82. The ChatGPT panel repeated at 0.36, as covered in how fast ChatGPT rebuilds its local recommendations. A pack position held between visits, and the AI Overview drew most of its names from that pack.
Google Business Profile work defends the stable surface
So what should an owner do about AI Overviews? On this data, nothing new, and that's the good news. Earn and hold a local pack spot with a complete Business Profile, steady honest reviews and real local relevance. That same work feeds the AI Overview above it.
There's no separate AI Overview playbook worth buying. Google says you don't need special schema or llms.txt files for its AI features. The AI Overview is reading Google's own index.
Measurement is the part worth changing. Check your market with full-question searches, since they trigger the AI layer three times as often. And because an AI Overview can vanish on the next check, judge yourself on pack presence. For ChatGPT and other AI tools, see how to optimize for AI search.
The questions owners ask most about AI Overviews and local search, answered from the study data.
Ready to hold the surface Google's AI reads from?
The pack is the durable asset, and the AI Overview drew most of its names from it. That makes your Business Profile, reviews and local relevance the whole game on this surface. Spearleaf builds exactly those basics for service businesses. To see whether your market's AI Overviews name businesses, and whether yours could be one, reach out through our contact page.
This article was written by Joshua Albanese, founder of Spearleaf, a local SEO and marketing agency based in Fort Myers, Florida. Joshua has built six businesses from zero using organic search and content, and he leads Spearleaf's SEO, AI search, and local strategy for service businesses across the U.S.